Subscribe to Newsletter
Outside the Lab Oncology, Screening and monitoring

The Lady Doth Co-Test Too Much, Methinks

Adult women are very familiar with the Pap smear – an unpleasant necessity in the name of preventing cervical cancer. Once the sample is taken, cells are microscopically examined for morphological abnormalities that indicate a precancerous state. Ideally, any patient whose cells show such indications can then be treated for the condition before it progresses to cancer. But the Pap test is not infallible, and many factors can lead to a false negative result.

Current guidelines recommend co-testing using both the Pap smear and human papillomavirus (HPV) testing every five years – but given rising costs, co-testing may be an unsustainable approach. What if there were a more sensitive way to detect precancers than Pap testing alone? That’s the question a research team at the National Institutes of Health’s National Cancer Institute asked themselves, seeking a way to reduce the incidence of a cancer that affects over half a million people worldwide every year (1). To find out, they quantified the differences in cervical cancer detection rates between co-testing and HPV testing alone – and came up with a surprising result.

HPV testing demonstrated a clear superiority to cytology, identifying significantly more patients with either precancer or overt cancer. Did the Pap smear catch any cases missed by HPV testing? Very few, according to the study results – only 3.5 percent of precancers and 5.9 percent of cancers, translating to five cases per million screens in a year at most. The authors’ conclusion? That co-testing isn’t necessary; very few patients benefit from the addition of cytology. The most cost-effective option, the results suggest, is to forgo the Pap smear and focus solely on HPV testing for the future prevention and detection of cervical cancer.

Receive content, products, events as well as relevant industry updates from The Pathologist and its sponsors.
Stay up to date with our other newsletters and sponsors information, tailored specifically to the fields you are interested in

When you click “Subscribe” we will email you a link, which you must click to verify the email address above and activate your subscription. If you do not receive this email, please contact us at [email protected].
If you wish to unsubscribe, you can update your preferences at any point.

  1. Cancer Research UK, “Cervical cancer incidence in Europe and Worldwide” (2014). Available at: bit.ly/2yRfmx1. Accessed November 17, 2017.
  2. M Schiffman et al., “Relative performance of HPV and cytology components of cotesting in cervical screening”, J Natl Cancer Inst, djx225 (2017).
About the Author
Michael Schubert

While obtaining degrees in biology from the University of Alberta and biochemistry from Penn State College of Medicine, I worked as a freelance science and medical writer. I was able to hone my skills in research, presentation and scientific writing by assembling grants and journal articles, speaking at international conferences, and consulting on topics ranging from medical education to comic book science. As much as I’ve enjoyed designing new bacteria and plausible superheroes, though, I’m more pleased than ever to be at Texere, using my writing and editing skills to create great content for a professional audience.

Related Application Notes
Tumor Genomic Profiling with SureSelect Cancer Tumor-Specific Assays

| Contributed by Agilent

Comprehensive Genomic Profiling with SureSelect Cancer CGP Assay

| Contributed by Agilent

Preventing Bias in scRNAseq Performed on Solid Tumors

| Contributed by Revvity

Related Product Profile
Diagnostics Genetics and epigenetics
QIAseq® Pan Cancer Multimodal cuts user interventions by 50%

| Contributed by QIAGEN

Most Popular
Register to The Pathologist

Register to access our FREE online portfolio, request the magazine in print and manage your preferences.

You will benefit from:
  • Unlimited access to ALL articles
  • News, interviews & opinions from leading industry experts
  • Receive print (and PDF) copies of The Pathologist magazine

Register